eruv

Question

Please help me understand the eruv issue. If one should not rely on even a carefully checked and maintained eruv in a community where the majority of the community (out of town) relies on the eruv, does this mean that mothers who have children who cannot yet walk, and the elderly and infirm who cannot walk are unable to participate in communal Shabbat life? When I have spent time in communities that do not have an eruv, such as in NY, I see Gentiles being hired to push baby carriages and wheelchairs, from what I understand,this is not okay either. I could certainly live without carrying anything but the baby on Shabbat. Having been blessed with not yet walking children continually for the past decade and a half, I do not know how I could learn to live Shabbat unable to leave the apartment with the children. Incidentally, correctly or not, when I was growing up (at the Jersey Shore) we did not know what an eruv was yet we pushed the carriage and the wheelchair on the Island. Thank you for helping me understand. This forum is very rapidly changing our lives in so many ways.

Answer

Answered by Aaron Abadi

A properly done Eiruv would possibly be OK. I have yet to see one. In a closed sort of community where there isn't really through traffic, it probably can be done. The laws of Eiruvin are so complex, you would really need a qualified Rabbi. Following the rules to the letter is not easy. That's why I suggest that everyone enjoy the benefits of the things that are permitted. Having a proper Shabbat life would be to keep the Mitzvot. If that means not going to the Synagogue, so be it. Wheelchairs & carriages if needed to go to a Mitzvah is permitted through a non-Jew. Aaron Abadi