Karpas

Question

With regard to using a banana for karpas, I saw that you quoted your father as saying "batlah daato etzel kok adam" I don't understand. Does he mean that most people don't regard a banana as a vegetable? But why is this significant -- if the berakahah is ha-adamah, why shouldn't it be good for karpas? Or does he meant that people coming to his seder will think he's crazy!

Answer

Answered by Aaron Abadi

No idea. Take it at face value and go on. It's not a Tosfos. AA