Psak

Question

You often make comments about Conservative poskim, many of which I agree with. However, they have one advantage - since they are, by definition, a new movement they have articulated there own system by which they decide halakha. Whether or not that has any value is a separate question. What would interest me is the beginning of an articulation of a valuable derekh hapsak. Cleary Rav Abadi is bold and willing to pasken what he thinks is correct, regardless of what the majority of the Orthodox community does. I wonder if you have developem a system for dealing with specific phenomena. For example: 1. How would you deal with a seif in the shulkan arukh which is machmir against Rov Rishonim and the pshat of the gemara? 2. What if the mechaber were meikel? 3. What if the Rema paskens a daat yachid - lchumra or lekula - would there be a threshold at which you would disagree? 4. Do you feel bound by mocern poskim at all - Rav Moshe, Tzizt Eliezer...? What about Nodah Byehuda and Hatam Sofer? 5. Do you ever pasken from the Gemara against the Shulkan Arukh? What about using the Rambam? I know that this seems very theoretical but I think that you would provide a great service to the community if you could lay out some basic principles.

Answer

Answered by Aaron Abadi

The rules of Psak cannot be explained on one foot. They are complex. The Conservative who even do away with just one Mitzvah are considered "Mumrim." AA