Mark S.

Question

Mark S:You have obviously not done the proper research, as you claim to have done. Extensive research is not required to realize that you are wrong. In Rav Yosef's teshuva he writes that after reading what Rabbi Wosner wrote he paskens that silk screening is assur. Yet you claim that he paskened this way because he saw the process. Now who's being dishonest? Also, where on this website do you see the claim that Rav Yosef holds it's kosher? You're making it seem that this website is run by a liar, when meanwhile a claim like that was never made. Rav Abadi is not basing his psak on what other rabbonim say. He's basing his psak on what he understands to be the truth. The fact that other rabbonim may disagree does not change a psak. I would assume that for Rav Abadi to say that silk screening is assur when he really believes it's kosher, is assur and would be considered lying. As far as your claim that Rav Yosef knows the real process but considers it assur, please explain to me where my mistake is in the following staement:Rav Yosef writes that when the sponge is put down the letters are now written ont he klaf. That's not true. The letters are now on a plastic. Only after the plastic is picked up do the letters get written. This is so pashut and clear that I don't see how after all your "research" you came to a differnt conclusion.