Re: Nutritional supplements
Question
B'Khavod, Thank you very much for your response to post #10023. Q2 asked, "...Do you find fish oil gel-caps to be considered food or non-food?" To this, CYA responded, "Food[, and] if you are taking it as a food to satiate yourself then it is a problem from a Kashrut standpoint and a Mental Health standpoint." My inference from this response is that the fish oil does not need to be from a kosher fish - since it is not intended for satiation. 1. Is this inference correct? 2. If so, would this logic apply to any encapsulated / tableted food not intended to satiate or provide consumptive pleasure, but only to provide healthful / nutritional benefits? 3. If one really hates the taste of a food substance (e.g., fish oil, liver, dry red wine) but consumes it solely for its healthful / nutritional value (any satiation is incidental), does one need to say birkat nehenin or b'racha aharona? 4. If one really hates the taste of a food substance (e.g., fish oil, liver, dry red wine) but consumes it solely for its healthful / nutritional value (any satiation is incidental), does the food substance need to be kosher? Thank you, and Tizkeh L'Misvoth! Jack D.
Answer
Answered by Chaim Yisrael AbadiAllow me to be specific about one thing. The previous post was about Nutrtional stuff recommended by a Medical professional, otherwise it can be a problem if it is edible. 1. NO, You cannot eat something that is unkosher even though you are not eating it for satiation 2. As per Medical professional 3. No and see #2 4. see intro CYA