Ta'aruvot (revised)
Question
1. Can one eat hard-boiled eggs (that were prepared in the chulent pot) with fish? 2. Can one eat hard-boiled eggs (that were prepared in the chulent pot) with dairy? 3. Can one boil a dairy "soup pouch" (sealed plastic bag of soup) in water in a ben yomo meat pot? 4. Can one boil a dairy "soup pouch" (sealed plastic bag of soup) in water in a non-ben yomo meat pot? 5. Technically speaking, if keli sheni does not cook -- is there a halachic need for separate meat and dairy dishes/utensils? Is there a difference here between bediavad and lechatechilla? (If possible, please provide the simanim in the SH"A that correspond to your answers.) Thanks!
Answer
Answered by Aaron Abadi1) In the olden days it was unhealthy to eat fish with meat. Some say that today the nature is different, and it is OK. Why take any risks. 2) no Good 3) It is my father's opinion that plastic is not Bolayah (does not retain flavor). If a scientist can prove otherwise, he'll back down from that opinion. 4) Same 5) Yes AA